We absolutely loved The Island City House Hotel! Booking by phone was easy, the stay was lovely and check out was quick and painless. The staff were all friendly and helpful. We stayed in the Cigar House (in back overlooking the pool/off street). Two nights in the 3rd story queen suite w/private balcony. It was quiet and comfortable and had... more

We just returned from a week-long visit to Florida which included a 3 night stay at the Island City House Hotel in Key West. The location was great- just a short walk to Mallory Square and Duval Street. The hotel is comprised of 3 buildings. We stayed in the Arch House. The room was clean and had a kitchenette but... more

This place is great!! Just stayed here 9 days, the service is excellent! Breakfast is good for a continental breakfast “bought from a local bakery” but gets a little old eating bagels and bread for a week. Sometimes they put out cinnamon buns which we always looked forward to getting YUMMY. Other than that the only other thing is parking... more

We spent a night at the Island City House during a tour of Florida in July 2008, and this was our favourite hotel of them all, despite being one of the least expensive. We had a two-bedroom suite with a single bathroom. It wasn't the biggest suite we've ever stayed in; both the bedrooms and the bathroom could best be... more

After about three weeks of searching through hotels on various websites we figured we would try a b and b instead of the common hotel chain. And doing so made an amazing selection with Island City House. Location was located just out of the hussel and bussel but also close enough to walk to Duval Street (nice 10 minute walk,... more

Wow! What a surprise! With the price of this place I didn't expect much. But we were very pleasantly surprised. I surprised my husband for his birthday and we had such a great time. It is not like your typical bed and breakfast where you know everyone staying there. It is much less personal, which we liked. Some people were... more

We stayed in the Arch House 5-8 July and it was lovely, just as pictured and described on their website. The house is very near to lots of things to see and do which makes it a great base for exploring Key West. The staff were extremely helpful, knowledgeable and willing to assist wherever possible. The breakfast was nice in... more

This was my first time in the Keys and I enjoyed it tremendously. My friend and I wanted to stay someplace clean, inexpensive, and close to Duval. It was the cleanest place we have ever stayed. The pictures of the room were very accurate. This fabulous bed and breakfast is within walking distance of Duval Street and Mallory Square. We... more

My husband and I had a truly wonderful time at the Island City House (and we're both pretty picky.) Our suite in the Cigar House was not extravagant, but clean and spacious. The staff did not have exhaustive knowledge (e.g. they did not have a bus schedule for me to look at) but they were very kind and genuinely friendly.... more