This vacation was the second-best trip of my life, and I'm pretty well traveled (the first-best was a trip to the Galapagoes). My wife and I were there for a half-week, and while we could have stayed for a longer trip (forever, really) we did a lot in the time we had, and came home fulfilled.
Way out among the reefs, Long Caye is a beautiful island where you can do all kinds of activities: kayaking, snorkling, windsurfing. Surf kayaking was a new one for me, but it was a blast. Even if you haven't done these things before, the guides are very helpful and nice. They will make sure that you enjoy yourselves thoroughly. And they have the best and most up-to-date gear.
This trip is great for couples or families because you can be as active or as laid back as you want. You can hang out with the other guests, or go for a walk or spend time in your private cabana.
The biggest surprise? The food was incredibly good! Unlike other vacations where you have to constantly wonder where your next meal is coming from, on Long Caye every meal we were surprised by some inventive flavor of lime, soy sauce, coconut or something else. Its tough to pick a favorite, but the ginger cookies and the fish tacos are contenders.
Generally I would say that having everything right there on the island made the vacation extremely relaxing. You don't have to worry about constantly arranging transportation and guides like you would on the mainland. All the activities are right off the shore of the island, and there is always something to do. Plus: hammocks, food, and a change of clothes are all right there too. It makes a big difference.
It turns out to be a deal, too. Everything is included, so compare it with the price of food, tranportation, guides, boat rides, etc. You will do more and have more fun with your vacation time if you go to Long Caye.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.